Is There a Real Life Historical Case Like This?
1) Direct answer
Yes. The Bible gives real historical cases that show exactly this principle.
2) Scriptural explanation
- Michal and David: Michal was David’s lawful wife. Saul later gave her to another man (Paltiel) while David still lived (1 Samuel 18:27; 25:44). When David demanded her, she was returned to him and the second union ended (2 Samuel 3:14–16). This shows the first marriage remained binding, and the later union had to cease.
- Sarah and Abimelech: Sarah was taken into Abimelech’s house under a mistaken assumption, but God said, “She is a man’s wife… restore the man his wife” (Genesis 20:2–7). Even in ignorance, God upheld the first covenant.
- Herod and Herodias: John said to Herod, “It is not lawful for thee to have thy brother’s wife” (Mark 6:17–18). While the first husband lived, the second relationship was condemned as unlawful.
- The rule stated: “If, while her husband liveth, she be married to another man, she shall be called an adulteress… but if her husband be dead, she is free” (Romans 7:2–3).
3) Simple clarifying logic
Now notice: in every case, the living first covenant governed the outcome. Mistake, time, or a second union did not dissolve it. Restoration to the original covenant—or separation from the unlawful union—was required.
4) Short reinforcing statement
You see, the Bible’s history and its doctrine match: the first bond stands while he lives.
Ask a Follow-up Question
What did the Laodicean Church Age (our age) Angel (- messenger) Say about this?
Ranked passages from the local William Branham sermon and Church Age Book database. Relevance is relative, not a statement of doctrinal certainty.
Questions and Answers, The Law having a shadow
54-0516 §50
All right, let's sing like this, all of us together, now, while they're getting...Let's sing. To be like Jesus, to be like Jesus, On earth I long to be like Him; All through life's journey from earth to glory, I only ask to be like Him. I'll sing the chorus, or the verse, you sing the chorus. From Bethlehem's manger came forth a stranger, On earth I long to be like Him; All through life's journey from earth to glory, I only ask to be like Him. Don't you want to be like Him? They're just about to get settled down, n...
A Hidden Life in Christ
55-1110 §44
And I'd forgot about them selling that fellow up there. I took out across the field to pray for this man. I got out there in the middle of the pasture. And when I did, all of a sudden out of a little clump of bushes, up raised this big bull. And he was right there in the mid... I looked back in the fence, and it was too far to run; no tree to get in. And there I was standing there. And here he come. Something happened. I wish I... I wish that would happen all the time. It just don't do it. But when I see a real tre...
The Trial
64-0419 §7
Well, he had been there about a year, and one day his mother took violent sick, she was real bad off. And they kept calling and sending telegrams. She was living by herself. That he might have to be called home because she took a real serious cold, and it run into double pneumonia, and had congestion in ... of the lungs, and she looked for to die. Her heart was showing up too bad. So the faithful physician was doing all that he knowed how to do to save the woman's life, and she constantly got worse. So the physicia...
The Law having a shadow
54-1203 §51
And the Holy Spirit said to me, "Come over here." And I went over. And as I sat down, I looked, and I saw like the world and it was revolving around. And around this world was a rainbow. It looked like a streak of red, like a rainbow going around and around the world. Then I went right into that, and when I was standing there in that, I looked and I seen somebody standing just above it with His arms out like this. It was our Lord. And I noticed myself, and every time I'd go do something wrong, just then according t...
Believing God
52-0224 §49
...cause He is not in human flesh. God is a Spirit. And we contact Him by spirit, through faith, believing. Now if we say I have a... When I had any hair, I had wavy hair just like my daddy. My daddy had close-set eyes, deep, blue. Many people say, "You look like your dad," or, "look like your mother." Well, I have a lot of things that's like my people. My old granddad built the Tabernacle here. Some say, "Oh, you're just like your granddad. You look like your granddad. You talk like him. You have a nature like him. W...